Happy Christmas and a bright new year from everyone at Genius Money Workforce Solutions

Legislation3 min read

PAYE vs CIS: what you need to know

PAYE and CIS affect tax, NI, admin and liability on construction jobs. With HMRC scrutiny and JSL changes ahead, contractors and workers need the right set-up.

By Aayush Gupta, Genius Money

If you're working in the construction sector, how you get paid, either through PAYE or under the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS), depends on how your hiring company engages its workforce.

At Genius, we ensure everything is done by the book, keeping both contractors and workers fully HMRC-compliant. Here's a breakdown of what each scheme means for you.

What PAYE means

PAYE (Pay As You Earn) is the standard method used to pay tax and National Insurance for employees. It's automatically deducted from your wages before they hit your bank account. If you're on the payroll of an umbrella company, you'll likely be paid this way.

What an umbrella company means

An umbrella company is often used by self-employed contractors who don't want to set up their own limited company. You technically become an employee of the umbrella, which processes your pay and deducts tax and NI under PAYE.

But here's where HMRC's concern comes in: some umbrella setups alter how tax is handled in ways that may raise compliance red flags. They change how workers pay tax and NI, sometimes straying into tax avoidance territory.

At Genius, we don't work like that. We operate as a CIS intermediary, which means we follow HMRC's CIS rules but structure engagement properly to protect everyone involved.

Why Joint and Several Liability (JSL) matters

With Joint and Several Liability (JSL) soon to be introduced, umbrella companies and potentially end clients could become jointly liable for unpaid PAYE and NI. This makes choosing the right payroll structure and a compliant partner like Genius more important than ever.

What CIS means

The Construction Industry Scheme has been around since the 1970s to reduce tax evasion in construction. Under CIS:

  • A flat 20% tax is deducted from subcontractor invoices (unless they have gross payment status)
  • Both contractors and subcontractors must register with HMRC
  • Genius handles this process on your behalf, taking the admin off your plate

What gross payment status means

Gross payment status means you receive your full invoice payments without deductions, and you sort out tax and NI via your self-assessment.

To qualify, you must:

  • Work in UK construction (or provide labour for it)
  • Use a business bank account
  • Have a good record of paying tax and NI on time
  • Meet the minimum turnover thresholds:
    • 30,000 for sole traders
    • 30,000 per partner (or 100,000 total) for partnerships
    • 30,000 per director (or 100,000 total) for limited companies

Switching from CIS to PAYE mid-year

Yes, you can move from CIS to PAYE during a tax year. Just be aware that you'll still need to submit a tax return for the CIS portion of the year.

What contractors are responsible for under CIS

If you're a contractor, here's what must be done each month:

  • Submit a CIS300 return to HMRC by the 19th of the following month
  • Provide subcontractors with payment and deduction statements

Miss a deadline and HMRC issues an immediate 100 fine, with escalating penalties the longer the return is overdue.

At Genius, we handle these tasks on your behalf, accurately and on time, so you can stay focused on the job.

In summary

The way you're paid matters for your take-home pay, your tax position, and your compliance. With JSL around the corner and increased HMRC scrutiny, now's the time to make sure your engagement structure is watertight.

Genius Money operates fully within HMRC guidelines, using the CIS scheme to protect contractors, workers, and agencies alike.

ShareLinkedInXEmail

Related reading

All news →

Questions about how this affects your workforce?

Talk to Genius Money. We deal with this every day, for clients and for the people on site.