Happy Christmas and a bright new year from everyone at Genius Money Workforce Solutions

Legislation1 min read

If the contract says one thing and the service does another, VAT is not optional

HMRC looks at the real labour supply, not just the contract. Construction firms should check VAT, CIS and PAYE treatment before paperwork becomes evidence against them.

By Aayush Gupta, Genius Money

A contract is not a costume. If the written agreement says one thing but the service delivered is something else, the paperwork does not protect the business. It becomes evidence.

That is the danger in parts of the construction labour market. Some arrangements are sold on the basis that they reduce VAT, payroll cost or employment responsibility. The problem is that HMRC does not only look at the words in the contract. It looks at what is actually happening.

Who controls the worker? Who supplies the labour? Who directs the work? Who carries the supervision? Who invoices whom? What service is really being provided? Does the VAT treatment match the real supply? Does the employment status match the practical reality?

If the answer is uncomfortable, the saving may not be a saving at all. It may be a tax exposure waiting to be found.

This matters especially in domestic construction and labour-heavy supply chains. Clients and providers may both know what is really happening, while relying on paperwork that describes something cleaner than the truth.

The service must match the terms. The tax treatment must match the service. You cannot use a contract to pretend that workers are not being supplied, controlled or paid in a way that creates tax obligations.

Checks that show whether the contract matches the service

  • Does the contract match the service actually delivered?
  • Is VAT being applied according to the real supply?
  • Does the worker status match the working reality?
  • Who controls the worker day to day?
  • Who carries payroll, PAYE, CIS and VAT responsibility?
  • Would the arrangement still make sense if HMRC read the contract and watched the work happen?

Genius can help construction businesses review payroll routes, VAT treatment, CIS/PAYE position, bookkeeping evidence and supplier contracts before HMRC asks the question.

If your contract does not match reality, call Genius before the paperwork becomes the evidence against you.

Contact Genius: 0207 700 2000 / hello@geniusmoney.co.uk.

ShareLinkedInXEmail

Related reading

All news →

Questions about how this affects your workforce?

Talk to Genius Money. We deal with this every day, for clients and for the people on site.